Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments

Community route

The order Xbox players typically unlocked these achievements, from real unlock times. It is a description of what people did — not advice, and not a walkthrough. For someone’s recommended order, see walkthroughs.

1. 1
   Bruiser

   Sapphire rarity,7.1%30G1 observationspread 0
2. 2
   Aye Aye, Captain!

   Uncommon rarity,24%15G1 observationspread 0
3. 3
   I Never Fail

   Uncommon rarity,15%70G1 observationspread 0
4. 4
   Sharpshooter

   Uncommon rarity,11%30G1 observationspread 0
5. 5
   Off the Rails!

   Uncommon rarity,15%15G1 observationspread 0
6. 6
   Child's Play!

   Uncommon rarity,14%30G1 observationspread 0
7. 7
   Keen Observer

   Uncommon rarity,13%30G1 observationspread 0
8. 8
   Elementary!

   Uncommon rarity,12%30G1 observationspread 0
9. 9
   Raider of the Tombs

   Uncommon rarity,12%30G1 observationspread 0
10. 10
    Blood and Ice

    Uncommon rarity,12%15G1 observationspread 0
11. 11
    An Omnivorous Reader

    Uncommon rarity,10%30G1 observationspread 0
12. 12
    My Grey Matters

    Uncommon rarity,10%70G1 observationspread 0
13. 13
    Hold your Herrings, Captain!

    Sapphire rarity,8.7%30G1 observationspread 0
14. 14
    Vox populi, vox Dei

    Uncommon rarity,11%15G1 observationspread 0
15. 15
    Suicide is Not an Option!

    Sapphire rarity,6.5%30G1 observationspread 0
16. 16
    A Deadly Flower

    Sapphire rarity,9.2%15G1 observationspread 0
17. 17
    Dog-fancier

    Amethyst rarity,3.3%30G1 observationspread 0
18. 18
    A Methodical Man

    Sapphire rarity,7.3%70G1 observationspread 0
19. 19
    Haunted House

    Sapphire rarity,8.0%30G1 observationspread 0
20. 20
    A Complex Mind

    Ruby rarity,0.96%70G1 observationspread 0
21. 21
    Perfectionist

    Ruby rarity,0.9%130G1 observationspread 0
22. 22
    Guilty Brotherhood

    Sapphire rarity,8.4%15G1 observationspread 0
23. 23
    Their Crimes, Your Punishments

    Sapphire rarity,8.5%30G1 observationspread 0
24. 24
    I Never Guess

    Amethyst rarity,4.8%70G1 observationspread 0
25. 25
    A Man of Character

    Amethyst rarity,2.3%70G1 observationspread 0

Ranked by median unlock position within sherlock holmes: crimes and punishments, computed 2026-10-24 · route-v1. Positions are counted inside this section only, so playing other content between these achievements does not affect the order. Aggregate figures only — no individual player’s history is shown.