Mafia I: Definitive Edition

Community route

The order Xbox players typically unlocked these achievements, from real unlock times. It is a description of what people did — not advice, and not a walkthrough. For someone’s recommended order, see walkthroughs.

1. 1
   Quite the Collection

   Uncommon rarity,24%20G1 observationspread 0
2. 2
   A Chase through the Night

   Common rarity,75%15G4 observationsspread 3
3. 3
   That Motor can Move

   Amethyst rarity,4.5%10G1 observationspread 0
4. 4
   Stunt Rider

   Amethyst rarity,4.2%10G1 observationspread 0
5. 5
   Car Enthusiast

   Sapphire rarity,6.7%10G1 observationspread 0
6. 6
   Family History

   Common rarity,62%10G2 observationsspread 1
7. 7
   Lined Pockets

   Uncommon rarity,13%10G1 observationspread 0
8. 8
   Not Taken In

   Uncommon rarity,11%10G1 observationspread 0
9. 9
   The Back Streets of Little Italy

   Common rarity,67%15G2 observationsspread 6
10. 10
    Pulp Fiction

    Common rarity,56%10G2 observationsspread 3
11. 11
    On the Trail

    Amethyst rarity,2.4%10G1 observationspread 0
12. 12
    Comic Violence

    Common rarity,33%10G2 observationsspread 3
13. 13
    Car Thief Number One

    Amethyst rarity,1.9%50G1 observationspread 0
14. 14
    The Way this City Works

    Common rarity,62%15G2 observationsspread 5.5
15. 15
    Mystery Fox Discovered

    Sapphire rarity,7.8%10G1 observationspread 0
16. 16
    Gangs of Lost Heaven

    Common rarity,56%15G2 observationsspread 4.5
17. 17
    Supercharged

    Common rarity,49%30G1 observationspread 0
18. 18
    Not Classy

    Amethyst rarity,1.6%10G1 observationspread 0
19. 19
    Neighborhood Hero

    Common rarity,48%15G1 observationspread 0
20. 20
    Good Night for a Walk Anyways

    Common rarity,47%15G1 observationspread 0
21. 21
    Storm Cloud over Chinatown

    Common rarity,46%15G1 observationspread 0
22. 22
    Murder in the House of God

    Common rarity,41%15G1 observationspread 0
23. 23
    Motor Museum

    Ruby rarity,0.9%50G1 observationspread 0
24. 24
    Your Canuck Cousins

    Common rarity,38%15G1 observationspread 0
25. 25
    Rat in the House

    Common rarity,37%15G1 observationspread 0
26. 26
    Blood on Beech Hill

    Common rarity,35%15G1 observationspread 0
27. 27
    Best Laid Plans

    Common rarity,34%15G1 observationspread 0
28. 28
    The Day the War Began

    Common rarity,33%15G1 observationspread 0
29. 29
    Death on the Water

    Common rarity,32%15G1 observationspread 0
30. 30
    When God Stops Smiling

    Common rarity,31%15G1 observationspread 0
31. 31
    Mystery Fox Domination

    Ruby rarity,0.6%50G1 observationspread 0
32. 32
    Heat from the Cops

    Uncommon rarity,22%10G1 observationspread 0
33. 33
    Full Set

    Ruby rarity,0.7%50G1 observationspread 0
34. 34
    The Day the War Ended

    Common rarity,30%15G1 observationspread 0
35. 35
    A View from the Top

    Common rarity,29%15G1 observationspread 0
36. 36
    Into the Lion's Den

    Common rarity,28%15G1 observationspread 0
37. 37
    That Last Big Score

    Common rarity,28%15G1 observationspread 0
38. 38
    Picture Book Connoisseur

    Ruby rarity,0.6%50G1 observationspread 0
39. 39
    Friends and Family

    Common rarity,27%15G1 observationspread 0
40. 40
    A Life of Crime

    Common rarity,27%50G1 observationspread 0
41. 41
    Lending Library

    Ruby rarity,0.6%50G1 observationspread 0
42. 42
    The Whole Story

    Ruby rarity,0.6%100G1 observationspread 0

Ranked by median unlock position within mafia i: definitive edition, computed 2026-10-06 · route-v1. Positions are counted inside this section only, so playing other content between these achievements does not affect the order. Aggregate figures only — no individual player’s history is shown.