Community route
The order Xbox players typically unlocked these achievements, from real unlock times. It is a description of what people did — not advice, and not a walkthrough. For someone’s recommended order, see walkthroughs.
19 of 25 achievements placed, from 2 players · Low confidence
- 1To the Moon!Common rarity,59%20G2 observationsspread 0.5
- 2Follow the Hype TrainCommon rarity,28%40G2 observationsspread 1
- 3Guess What's ComingCommon rarity,48%40G2 observationsspread 0.5
- 4Back to Back Jacks!Common rarity,35%70G2 observationsspread 1
- 5Future of the FranchiseSapphire rarity,6.3%40G1 observationspread 0
- 6Here comes the paint!Uncommon rarity,20%70G2 observationsspread 1
- 7Heart of the CityUncommon rarity,19%40G2 observationsspread 3.5
- 8This Day in HistoryUncommon rarity,12%40G2 observationsspread 1.5
- 9Make The DanceAmethyst rarity,2.2%70G1 observationspread 0
- 10Designated DingerCommon rarity,40%40G2 observationsspread 0.5
- 11This Hobby of MineUncommon rarity,11%20G2 observationsspread 1.5
- 12Just Getting StartedUncommon rarity,16%20G2 observationsspread 0.5
- 13Quick TurnaroundRuby rarity,0.96%70G1 observationspread 0
- 14Old SchoolSapphire rarity,8.8%40G2 observationsspread 3
- 15Brand DealUncommon rarity,20%20G2 observationsspread 0.5
- 16If You Love Something...Uncommon rarity,13%20G2 observationsspread 1.5
- 17Baseball Beats to Play ToAmethyst rarity,4.0%20G1 observationspread 0
- 18Unparalleled ProSapphire rarity,6.7%70G2 observationsspread 2
- 19Practice Makes PerfectUncommon rarity,16%20G1 observationspread 0
Ranked by median unlock position within mlb® the show™ 23, computed 2026-10-01 · route-v1. Positions are counted inside this section only, so playing other content between these achievements does not affect the order. Aggregate figures only — no individual player’s history is shown.