MLB The Show 24 Xbox One

Community route

The order Xbox players typically unlocked these achievements, from real unlock times. It is a description of what people did — not advice, and not a walkthrough. For someone’s recommended order, see walkthroughs.

1. 1
   Setting the Tone

   Common rarity,51%20G3 observationsspread 1
2. 2
   Kitchen Sink

   Common rarity,54%40G3 observationsspread 2
3. 3
   The Best Offense is No Offense

   Common rarity,51%40G3 observationsspread 1
4. 4
   Walk Off, Do Your Dance

   Common rarity,32%40G3 observationsspread 9.5
5. 5
   A Double Play Would Be Nice Here

   Common rarity,48%20G3 observationsspread 3
6. 6
   Pure Speed

   Common rarity,51%40G3 observationsspread 3.5
7. 7
   Chin Up Champ

   Common rarity,46%20G3 observationsspread 3
8. 8
   Ambush!

   Common rarity,39%40G3 observationsspread 3.5
9. 9
   Trading Places

   Common rarity,44%40G3 observationsspread 7.5
10. 10
    If You Stare, it Might Stay Fair

    Common rarity,56%20G3 observationsspread 9
11. 11
    Speed or Luck or Both?

    Common rarity,40%40G3 observationsspread 4.5
12. 12
    Gotta Be Quicker Than That

    Common rarity,33%20G3 observationsspread 7.5
13. 13
    Red Hot Baserunning

    Uncommon rarity,15%70G3 observationsspread 3.5
14. 14
    Swan Dive Defense

    Uncommon rarity,22%40G3 observationsspread 8
15. 15
    Stay in School

    Common rarity,46%20G3 observationsspread 2.5
16. 16
    Derby Level Damage

    Common rarity,45%20G3 observationsspread 5
17. 17
    40/40 Watch?

    Common rarity,30%70G3 observationsspread 5.5
18. 18
    Good Grelief

    Sapphire rarity,5.7%70G2 observationsspread 1.5
19. 19
    Maddux

    Uncommon rarity,23%70G3 observationsspread 3
20. 20
    Save Some for Tomorrow

    Uncommon rarity,11%70G3 observationsspread 1.5
21. 21
    Living On the Field

    Common rarity,36%70G3 observationsspread 6.5
22. 22
    Open the Tool Box

    Uncommon rarity,18%40G3 observationsspread 0.5
23. 23
    Empty the Tank

    Common rarity,29%40G3 observationsspread 3.5
24. 24
    Supposed to be My Day Off

    Sapphire rarity,7.6%20G3 observationsspread 2.5
25. 25
    Celebrity Shot

    Sapphire rarity,8.8%20G3 observationsspread 0.5

Ranked by median unlock position within mlb® the show™ 24 xbox one, computed 2026-10-07 · route-v1. Positions are counted inside this section only, so playing other content between these achievements does not affect the order. Aggregate figures only — no individual player’s history is shown.