Tell Me Why

Community route

The order Xbox players typically unlocked these achievements, from real unlock times. It is a description of what people did — not advice, and not a walkthrough. For someone’s recommended order, see walkthroughs.

1. 1
   Mailbox Bandit

   Sapphire rarity,6.6%50G2 observationsspread 0
2. 2
   Just One Fix

   Sapphire rarity,5.9%50G2 observationsspread 0
3. 3
   Are You My Daddy?

   Uncommon rarity,14%50G2 observationsspread 0
4. 4
   Fish all the Fish

   Uncommon rarity,13%50G2 observationsspread 0
5. 5
   The Princess' Lost Treasure

   Uncommon rarity,13%50G1 observationspread 0
6. 6
   And Everything In Its Place

   Amethyst rarity,2.9%50G2 observationsspread 0.5
7. 7
   Lock-Up And Go

   Uncommon rarity,12%50G2 observationsspread 0.5
8. 8
   Twins4life

   Uncommon rarity,13%50G2 observationsspread 0.5
9. 9
   Life Tears Us Apart

   Amethyst rarity,1.9%50G1 observationspread 0
10. 10
    A New Chapter

    Amethyst rarity,2.4%50G1 observationspread 0

Ranked by median unlock position within tell me why: chapter 3, computed 2026-10-05 · route-v1. Positions are counted inside this section only, so playing other content between these achievements does not affect the order. Aggregate figures only — no individual player’s history is shown.